Republicans clash with Trump: Tate brothers back in US amid trafficking charges
Tate brothers' return to the US fuels backlash and raises questions about Trump’s involvement, Feb. 28, 2025. (Collage by Türkiye Today/Mehmet Akbas)
A little over a month has passed since Donald Trump’s inauguration, and the president has already inspired several topics of debate, with a new one now involving the Tate brothers.
What has happened in Donald Trump’s first month as president?
His threats to Hamas and bold statements regarding taking over Gaza caused a significant backlash but were praised by Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. His more recent “Trump Gaza” video on Truth Social increased concerns regarding the potential involvement of the United States in Palestine.
Furthermore, his approach to the Russia-Ukraine war, his recent conversations with and about Vladimir Putin have raised further questions on United States’ broader conflict strategy.
On the economic front, Trump’s recently announced tarrifs, the mention of a possible $5 million “gold card” visa, the proposal of a republican governor to introduce a $250 dollar bill featuring Trump have attracted significant attention.
How did the Tate brothers resurface in the United States?
Now, Donald Trump seems to have shifted his attention back to those he considers unfairly incriminated.
The first ones who came to mind were far-right influencer and self-described misogynist Andrew Tate and his brother Tristan, who have been charged with human trafficking, sexual misconduct, and money laundering. The fact that the Tate brothers’ return coincides with the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files seems to be an ironic coincidence.
So, let’s have a look at why Andrew and Tristan are currently on trial in Romania, why Donald Trump endorsed their return and now refuses to admit he had learned about their return, the brothers’ reception in Florida, and the American right’s negative reactions to Trump’s politics.
Far-right influencer Andrew Tate and brother’s legal troubles in Romania
The Tate brothers, who hold dual U.S.-U.K. citizenship, were arrested in Romania in late 2022 and charged with:
- Human trafficking
- Rape
- Money laundering
Prosecutors alleged that the two lured women to Romania under false pretenses and forced them into sexual exploitation. Andrew Tate is a former kickboxer and self-described misogynist who has consistently denied all allegations, claiming that he is the target of a politically motivated campaign.
A Romanian court ruled in December 2024 that the case could not proceed due to procedural issues, but:
- The charges remain active
- Prosecutors continue their investigation
- Authorities unexpectedly lifted the brothers’ travel restrictions in February 2025
Donald Trump administration’s involvement: Tate brothers’ legal defense
Financial Times recently suggested that members of the Trump administration played a role in facilitating the Tate brothers’ return to the United States.
Trump’s special envoy, Richard Grenell, reportedly raised the issue with Romania’s foreign minister at the Munich Security Conference earlier this month.
Sources familiar with the matter stated that U.S. officials encouraged Romania to return the brothers’ passports and lift travel restrictions while they awaited trial. Grenell later downplayed his role, claiming he had “no substantive conversation” about the Tates.
However, Trump denied knowledge of the situation, stating:
I just know nothing about it. We’ll check it out. We’ll let you know.
Despite his denial, the involvement of his administration has fueled speculation about Trump’s relationship with right-wing internet influencers.
The Tate brothers’ lawyer, Joseph McBride, directly referenced Trump when discussing their return.
The primary reason the Tate brothers feel safe to return to the United States is that Donald Trump is the president. (The Tate brothers) are excited to call America their home again
Lawyer Joseph McBride said in a recent statement.
He also mentioned Andrew and Tristan’s plan to return to Romania at the end of March for legal proceedings before coming back to the U.S.
However, Donald Trump’s administration’s apparent support for the Tates has fueled speculation about his connections to right-wing internet influencers.
Conservatives react to the Tates’ returning to United States
While some far-right figures praised their release, many conservatives condemned Trump’s alleged involvement.
Ben Shapiro posted on X:
America does not need more self-proclaimed pimps and terror supporters with outstanding criminal allegations of sex trafficking and a history of pornographic distribution, plus a grift ‘university’ that suckers young men out of thousands of dollars.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis also distanced himself during a news conference:
We have no involvement in [their return]. I read about it through the media. Florida is not a place where you’re welcome with that type of conduct.
Other conservatives questioning the move include:
- Sen. Josh Hawley, who expressed concerns about the implications of U.S. intervention in the case, stated that he hoped the government had no role in facilitating the Tate brothers’ return.
- Conservative radio host Erick Erickson argued that the decision demonstrated how Trump’s administration was increasingly catering to internet-driven movements rather than focusing on broader conservative principles.
- Candace Owens defended the move by suggesting that allowing the Tate brothers to return was a win for due process and individual rights, reinforcing her stance against what she calls politically motivated legal persecution.
How did right-wing influencers react to Tate brothers’ return?
There were differing reactions to the Trump administration’s decision to help out the Tate brothers while their case is ongoing in Romania. However, it is easy to notice that the majority of the negative reactions within the far-right movement came from women.
- Republican influencer Abby Libby expressed her disappointment with the Trump administration for a “stunning betrayal” of their mandate to “get rapists and pedophiles off the streets”.
Her tweet received a lot of responses and several theories were proposed regarding the reason he decided to make such a controversial move.
While some argued that he was trying to get the approval of Andrew Tate’s audience, others claimed that Trump was trying to distract people until he blurred his ties with Epstein before the documents went public.
Andrew Tate’s influence on young men raises concerns
Andrew Tate has amassed a large following online by promoting hyper-masculine and misogynistic views. His influence extends beyond social media, with real-world consequences.
- In 2024, a U.K. university student inspired by Tate was arrested for plotting a mass shooting
- Authorities have linked Tate’s messaging to the radicalization of young men, particularly through platforms like X (formerly Twitter), YouTube, and private Discord groups
Despite these concerns, Tate’s supporters continue to portray him as a champion of free speech and masculinity. His rhetoric, which includes claims that feminism has “weakened men,” has contributed to his cult-like following, making him a significant figure in the digital right-wing sphere.
What’s next for Tate brothers?
Despite their return to the U.S., the Tate brothers remain under legal scrutiny:
- Romanian prosecutors emphasize that their case is still open, and the brothers are required to return for judicial proceedings.
- The U.K. has issued arrest warrants for the brothers in a separate case related to sexual violence.
- A lawsuit was filed in Florida by a woman who alleges that she was coerced into sex work and later defamed by them.
Trump’s distancing from the controversy suggests that he may be aware of the backlash. The split within the conservative movement—between traditional Republicans and hyper-online influencers—raises questions about the future of Trump’s coalition.
For now, the Tate brothers frame their return as a victory. Andrew Tate told reporters:
We live in a democratic society where it’s innocent until proven guilty. My brother and I are largely misunderstood.
However, with multiple legal battles looming, the Tate brothers’ future—and Trump’s involvement—remains far from settled.
History of PKK terrorist group’s disarmament and making sense of Imrali’s call
How Turkish media covered Ocalan’s historic call for PKK terrorist group dissolution
US, Russia take initial steps to stabilize diplomatic missions in Istanbul talks
